As an aerospace neuropsychologist, my role centers on evaluating pilots' cognitive functions to ensure aviation safety. The recent tragic events in aviation, including the Philadelphia medical jet crash, Alaska Airlines incident and the midair collision between an American Airlines passenger jet and an Army Black Hawk helicopter near Washington, D.C., have shaken public confidence in air travel. These accidents, which resulted in devastating consequences, highlight the inherent risks of aviation. However, it is important to clarify that cognitive or psychological issues have not been indicated as relevant factors in these recent incidents. Instead, they remind us of the multiple layers of safety protocols and oversight required to keep air travel as safe as possible.
These events make me reflect on my own work in the field. My role is just one part of the broader aviation safety system, but it is a critical one. I assess pilots to help ensure that they have the cognitive and psychological capabilities necessary for the immense responsibility of operating an aircraft. While my work does not address mechanical failures, the role of weather conditions, air traffic control miscommunications, or other operational concerns, it focuses on the human element—ensuring that pilots are equipped to handle high-pressure situations with clarity, precision, and sound judgment.
The Importance of Neuropsychological Testing in Aviation
Neuropsychological evaluations are designed to assess various cognitive domains, including measures of visual scanning and tracking, attention, reaction time, short- and long-term memory, visual-perceptual speed, divided attention, psychomotor tracking, math reasoning, novel problem-solving, and multitasking ability. These functions are essential for pilots, as they directly impact decision-making, situational awareness, and the ability to respond effectively under pressure. The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) mandates such evaluations, especially for pilots with known neurological conditions, to ensure they can operate aircraft safely.
Addressing Misconceptions About Testing Relevance
A common misconception is that neuropsychological tests are unrelated to actual flying tasks. However, research has demonstrated that performance on these tests correlates with outcomes in flight simulators, which are predictive of real-world flying performance. For instance, the CogScreen-Aeromedical Edition (CogScreen-AE), a computerized test battery, has been shown to predict both actual and simulated flight performance in commercial and general aviation.
The Role of Mental Health in Aviation Safety
Beyond cognitive functioning, we also assess mental health for aviation safety. Conditions such as recurrent or intractable depression, suicidality, severe anxiety, panic attacks, psychosis, mood swings, and alcoholism can significantly impact a pilot’s ability to perform their duties safely. Mental health stability is critical for managing the high-stress environment of aviation, ensuring pilots can make sound decisions under pressure and maintain emotional regulation during flights.
Challenges Pilots Face in Reporting Mental Health Issues
Despite the importance of mental health in aviation, many pilots are reluctant to report concerns due to the potential impact on their medical certification and career. The FAA has stringent policies surrounding certain mental health disclosures, which can create fear of job loss or extended grounding periods. As a result, pilots may avoid seeking help or downplay symptoms. Addressing this issue requires a nuanced approach that balances aviation safety with a supportive system for pilots to access care without unnecessary career repercussions. Open discussions and policy refinements can help mitigate these challenges, ensuring pilots receive the support they need while maintaining the highest safety standards.
Balancing Safety and Professional Aspirations
While the results of these evaluations may sometimes be disappointing to pilots, the overarching goal is collaborative: to ensure the safety of the aerospace environment. Holding a pilot's license is a privilege that requires intact reasoning, judgment, and other cognitive faculties. This is analogous to other professions, such as medical doctors or attorneys, where practitioners must maintain certain standards to ensure public safety. No pilot—or anyone in the field of aviation—wants to be a risk to themselves or others. Our evaluations are not about keeping people out of the cockpit but about making sure they are ready and able to handle the immense responsibility that comes with flying.
Preparing for Your Evaluation
If you are a pilot or pilot candidate seeking an evaluation, here are some important points to consider:
Testing may require one or two days, depending on the situation. In some cases, the FAA mandates an additional day of testing, which would be discussed after your initial appointment. If you have questions about what to expect in your particular situation, please request a phone call with our aerospace evaluations coordinator, Kim, at (336) 542-1800.
For ADHD referrals, the FAA requires a urine drug screen (UDS) within 24 hours after each day of testing. You should schedule this on your own—Labcorp at 1126 N Church St, Ste 104, (336) 272-5021, is a recommended option. Online scheduling is available, and drug screening is only conducted between 8 AM and 3:30 PM. The cost of the UDS is separate from the evaluation. Testing is required for amphetamine and methylphenidate only, and results should be faxed to our office at (336) 542-1888. Dr. Renfroe will provide you with an order on the day of your appointment.
The FAA provides a checklist of required documents for ADHD evaluations. These should be submitted to our office, in addition to your AME, before your evaluation.
It is crucial to be well-rested and manage stress levels leading up to the evaluation. The tests are highly sensitive to fatigue and anxiety. Avoid traveling long distances on the day of your evaluation, as this can negatively impact performance. There is no way to "study" for the testing; simply ensure that you are physically and mentally prepared, have all required documentation submitted, and have scheduled the necessary urine test if applicable.
Conclusion
The recent airline tragedies serve as a somber reminder of the importance of thorough cognitive and psychological evaluations in aviation. These events reinforce why every aspect of aviation safety, including aerospace neuropsychology, plays a role in protecting lives. As aerospace neuropsychologists, our mission is to identify potential cognitive weaknesses that could pose hazards, thereby enhancing aviation safety. By ensuring that pilots possess the necessary cognitive and emotional stability, we aim to contribute to the prevention of accidents and uphold the trust placed in the aviation industry.
Comments